My wife and I recently took a bus tour around Ireland. The tour concentrated on the scenic parts of Ireland, where wind turbines are largely restricted. But we passed some turbines, and a fellow traveler commented that "windmills are useless. Don't you have coal?"
The tour guide handled the comment tactfully, I thought. No, we don't have coal. We have to import our fuel. He acknowledged "those giant bird killers" with a grin and did not confront their perspective. We moved on, and the tour guide described passing scenery, offered historical tidbits, and told Irish tall tales.
The incident made me mutter to my wife about skyscrapers killing more birds than windmills do. But that evening I looked up estimated numbers of birds killed. Close to 700,000 birds are killed by wind turbines each year, according to one source. That's a lot of birds, and that's just the US.
However, for each bird killed by wind turbines:
- 7 birds are killed by communication towers
- 60 birds are killed by power lines
- 200 birds are killed by vehicles
- 600 birds are killed by windows
- 2600 birds are killed by cats
This is sad news. I like birds. They sing. Billions of them die because of us. They still sing.
But numbers aren't the whole story, either. Wind turbines are particularly lethal to raptors. Even though they don't sing, eagles mean more to us than robins. There is legitimate concern about wind turbines, never mind those voracious cats.
Fortunately, a variety of technologies are being implemented to reduce bird deaths caused by turbines. Some towers are equipped with sensors to detect large birds and shut down the turbines until the coast is clear. Some turbines shut down during large migration events. One potential solution is as simple as painting one blade black, which seems to provide better visibility and reduces collisions by up to 70%.
Most of the solutions are still experimental and, though showing promise, require more study. These provide a good start on our toolbox for addressing bird casualties. I wish we were devoting similar resources to the cat problem!
As it turns out, changes to climate also affect birds. Red belly woodpeckers never used to be in Michigan; now I see and hear them regularly. They seem to have decided that up north ain't so bad, now that it ain't so cold. But changes to environment are causing longer migrations and increased vulnerability. Some estimates are that climate changes are the the most deadly cause for declining bird populations. Another study indicates that fossil-fuel power plants kill 13 to 17 times as many birds as wind turbines per gigawatt/hour produced.
If you don't believe that climate is changing, then you also might find these studies suspect. If you believe the climate is changing but it's not our fault, you might still be concerned for the birds. Or maybe you think caring is for the birds. If you take science seriously you are aware that climate change is primarily caused by human activity, which means we have some responsibility for addressing it. I hope you care enough about birds and the rest of creation to attempt to help protect these treasures.
A day or two after the comment about windmills, our tour took us through central Ireland on our way back to Dublin. We passed farm country and a lot of wind turbines. This was the point in the tour at which the guide's narrative included wind energy. "We don't have coal," he said. "We don't have oil. We don't have gas. But we do have a lot of wind. Each of those turbines produces enough electricity to power 1300 homes."
As he spoke, a bird hit the windshield.